I'm not sure how low down pads are meant to wear, but they were only about 1mm off the new EBC HH ones (exact same type) which I found a bit odd.
They've been on there about 4k I think but I've really no idea how long they're meant to last. I wasn't paying much attention last time I changed them, but the BMW pads looked a lot more worn than the EBC ones I've just replaced.
Assuming the old pads are fine, and the new ones have cured the metal on metal noise under braking then is it just a case of "they all do that?"

What do you find in the best way to judge how worn your pads are, I find it rather hard to tell.

Cheers!
Ads
ps...I highly recommend the Nightsearcher Rechargeable Fluorescent Lantern from Machine Mart for all those that don't have the luxury of power/lighting in their garage. At £30 it's a bargain.